Makhachkala residents criticized officials for their lack of response to their appeals and complaints.
Residents of Makhachkala complained that appeals to specialized services regarding the lack of electricity, water, and heating go unanswered or end with formal replies, and this problem has been relevant for several years, commenting on the mayor's order for subordinates to respond promptly to citizens' appeals.
As reported by "Caucasian Knot", on November 11, the head of Makhachkala, Jambulat Salavov, demanded that the heads of resource supply organizations respond promptly to citizens' appeals and monitor the resolution of each problem. According to the mayor, complaints should not go unanswered, and working with them should lead to concrete results. However, residents of Makhachkala noted that they often cannot get responses to appeals even to Salavov himself.
Last weekend, due to work on the Miatlinskie water pipelines, residents of several districts of Makhachkala were left without water for several days. Citizens complained that the addresses of the outages were reported late, the promised water delivery was practically non-existent, and their calls to the hotline went unanswered.
Ignoring appeals to specialized services has become a problem for Makhachkala residents
Calling dispatchers is useless; even if they receive the signal, nothing gets resolved.
Appeals regarding the lack of water supply to the Telegram channels of the Makhachkala administration and the Unified Operator in the water supply sector did not help solve the problem, said local resident Kadi.
"City hall employees did not respond, and the operator sent a message saying, 'We are aware of the problem and are working on its resolution.' Judging by the fact that the exact same text was in response to other complaints, it was likely a bot responding," he told a correspondent from "Caucasian Knot".
According to Kadi, due to three days without water and heating, he had to temporarily send his children to relatives living in a private house. They have a tank with a water supply and their own gas heating.
Resident of Rasul Gamzatov Street Kazim also could not reach any emergency service. According to him, there was no information about the timeline for restoring water supply, and residents did not notice the promised water delivery.
"There was no information about specific timelines for water supply. Water trucks did not appear anywhere; at least no resident reported this, and, as was the case in similar situations before, no photos of water trucks on the streets were published on official resources. We had to buy bottled water, but it ran out in nearby stores by the second day," the man told a correspondent from "Caucasian Knot".
The lack of water created problems for a family with two children, complained resident of Stoyan Dzhorov Street Aminat.
"I have two children. Due to the lack of water, I couldn't wash their clothes or bathe them over the weekend. On Monday, November 16, there was also no water, and I had to keep them home from school. I also couldn't properly prepare food due to the lack of water and clean dishes," she told a correspondent from "Caucasian Knot".
Aminat said that the Unified Operator did not respond to her appeals, and no one answered the hotline calls.
Another resident of Makhachkala Tagir complained that the ineffectiveness of appeals to utility services has become a constant problem.
"For the past few years, I have had to send complaints about various issues – lack of electricity, water, heating. The only time there was a real response was when I contacted the Housing Inspection. Other services do not respond," Tagir told a correspondent from "Caucasian Knot".
He also used the feedback platform "State Services. Solving Together". According to him, appeals are accepted there but then forwarded to different instances, making it impossible to achieve a prompt resolution of the problem.
Utility services often know about the problem but do not inform residents when it will be resolved, another Makhachkala resident, Aslan, reported. According to his observations, sometimes it is possible to get a response from officials after publishing complaints in the media and public forums.
"Calling dispatchers is useless; even if they receive the signal, nothing gets resolved. Now many people are turning to feedback bots of independent Telegram channels and media <…>. Surprisingly, sometimes officials respond to them. Why doesn't the Makhachkala administration create such a feedback channel with residents, where every complaint would receive a response and the responsible executor would be named?" Aslan told a correspondent from "Caucasian Knot".
A lawyer pointed out the obligation of authorities to organize water delivery
Authorities must organize water delivery within a day
In case of prolonged water supply interruption, the city administration is obliged to organize the delivery of drinking water, lawyer Rustam Akhmedov pointed out. According to him, under the federal law "On Water Supply and Water Disposal", local authorities must provide residents with drinking water within a day, including through delivery, if water supply is interrupted or limited due to an accident, planned preventive repairs, or other reasons.
Water delivery is the responsibility of the Makhachkala administration, Akhmedov emphasized. In his opinion, a formal response stating that the issue falls under the competence of the resource supply organization has no legal grounds. In case of prolonged water absence, residents have the right to appeal to the prosecutor's office and, if necessary, to the court.
The lawyer recommended first of all to document appeals to the emergency dispatch service: demand a request number, the time of its acceptance, the name or position of the employee. Then, the appeal should be duplicated in writing through the GIS Housing and Utilities, the personal account of the management company or resource supply organization, email, "State Services", or by registered mail.
If representatives of the management company or the Unified Operator refuse to draw up an act on the lack of water, the resident can do this independently, gathering signatures from at least two neighbors and a representative of the apartment building council, Akhmedov explained. The act should be sent to the management and resource supply organizations, the city administration, and the State Housing Inspection.
"If the city administration did not organize delivery within a day in case of water absence, the disconnection poses a threat to life, health, and freezing of the house, and the resource supply organization and housing inspection ignore appeals, then one should appeal to the prosecutor's office, attaching request numbers, acts, photos, correspondence, and responses from authorities. If there is still no response, one can go to court with a demand for recalculation, compensation for actual damage, penalties, moral damages, and legal expenses. References can be made to part 4 of article 157 of the Housing Code of the Russian Federation, paragraphs 98 and 101 of the Rules for Providing Utility Services, approved by the Government of the Russian Federation on 06.05.2011 No. 354, articles 15 and 1064 of the Civil Code of the Russian Federation," the lawyer reported.
Translated automatically via OpenAI from https://www.kavkaz-uzel.eu/articles/428441





![Tumso Abdurakhmanov. Screenshot from video posted by Abu-Saddam Shishani [LIVE] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mIR3s7AB0Uw Tumso Abdurakhmanov. Screenshot from video posted by Abu-Saddam Shishani [LIVE] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mIR3s7AB0Uw](/system/uploads/article_image/image/0001/18460/main_image_Tumso.jpg)