Commentators supported the protest of the Kuban activist against the euthanasia of stray dogs.
Determining the aggression of stray dogs in ten days may be unreliable, and instead of euthanizing animals, authorities could allocate funds for shelters, said commentators on social media who supported the picket of Kuban activist Valentina Shostak against the euthanasia of stray animals. Their opponents pointed out that stray dogs form packs, carry diseases, and attack people, so their population needs to be regulated.
As reported by "Caucasian Knot", on November 13, resident of Hot Key Valentina Shostak held a solo picket outside the administration building of Krasnodar Krai against amendments to the governor's decrees on the treatment of stray animals. According to the activist, the changes will allow for the euthanasia of dogs deemed aggressive ten days after capture, and due to stress during capture, almost any animal can be recognized as aggressive.
Users debated ways to solve the problem of stray dogs
Valentina Shostak's picket against the amendments to the governor's decrees on the treatment of stray animals sparked discussion among social media users. On the "Caucasian Knot" Facebook page*, which has about 164 thousand followers, two posts about Shostak's protest against the cruel treatment of stray animals were published. As of 15:30 MSK on November 16, these posts collectively garnered 164 comments.
Some commentators supported Shostak. "Well done, even one in the field is a warrior. Kind people will still join you and support you in your noble cause. Good luck. Stay strong," wrote Tatiana Vozmilova.
"What a great person, but why alone? Is there really no one else in Krasnodar who agrees with her and is compassionate towards the tails? People, do not remain indifferent to those who cannot defend themselves," wrote Lyudmila Mikhailova.
Other users criticized the proposed euthanasia of dogs and suggested alternative ways to solve the problem. Nadyusha Kravetskaya doubted the possibility of reliably determining an animal's aggression in ten days. "We have a case where an animal took 1.5 years to adapt to a new family after being beaten in the old one and now lives as a very affectionate, normal family member. And another question: who determines the aggression of an animal? What specialists? A normal dog trainer, for example, will tell you that any dog needs work. Only a few cannot be corrected in behavior," she noted.
"Is it really impossible to pass a law (local regulation) so that local and regional authorities allocate a small fraction (finally introduce a penny collection) for shelters and food for animals? This could ultimately create jobs for people with disabilities," suggested Alexander V. Pirogov.
Some participants in the discussion pointed out the danger that stray dogs pose to people and advocated for regulating their population. "In the USSR, the population of stray dogs was regulated. And this is correct. The idea of keeping them is unreasonable. They become wild, form packs, destroy the fauna in the vicinity, carry diseases, and attack people," wrote Dinar Sharipov.
Alexey Bryantsev provided statistical data attributed to Rospotrebnadzor. "The number of bites, scratches, and attacks by animals in 2025 in Russia amounted to 390 thousand. Such data was provided by the chair of the working group in the State Duma on improving legislation aimed at protecting citizens from attacks by stray animals, Nina Ostanina, at a meeting on May 25," he wrote.
Debates about the cruel treatment of stray animals have been relevant in southern Russia for a long time
In the southern regions of Russia, the issue of cruel treatment of stray dogs has repeatedly sparked disputes between animal rights activists and supporters of regulating the population of homeless animals. This confrontation was particularly acute in the Astrakhan region, where residents demanded that authorities protect them from animal attacks. In March 2023, the body of a woman with dog bite marks was found in Astrakhan. Investigators considered the attack by stray animals as one of the versions of her death.
Against the backdrop of residents' dissatisfaction, Astrakhan regional Duma deputy Evgeny Dunaev proposed in December 2023 to euthanize dogs that were not taken from temporary holding points within 15 days. Animal rights activists opposed the initiative, calling it excessively cruel, after which the bill was withdrawn. However, supporters of tightening the rules held their own rally, and the regional Duma soon adopted another law allowing the euthanasia of unviable and aggressive stray animals.
The confrontation did not end there. In March 2025, authorities introduced a state of emergency in the Privolzhsky district of the Astrakhan region, allowing the capture of all stray dogs, including sterilized ones, and the euthanasia of unclaimed animals after 30 days of holding.
Debates about whether it is permissible to euthanize animals for the safety of people also took place in the Stavropol Krai. The law adopted there allowed euthanasia of dogs in limited cases, including aggression towards humans. Animal rights activists considered these provisions excessive and appealed to the court. In March of this year, the regional court refused to recognize the law as invalid, but activists announced their intention to appeal the decision, citing the lack of transparency in the criteria for determining animal aggression.
Concerns of animal rights activists regarding the application of such criteria were also manifested in Karachay-Cherkessia. After the authorities introduced a state of emergency, local activists complained in September about the mass euthanasia of stray dogs and violations during their capture. According to animal rights activists, animals can be deemed aggressive due to their natural reaction to stress during capture, and the decision-making procedure for euthanasia does not ensure independent oversight.
The danger of attacks by stray animals raised concerns among residents of other regions in southern Russia. For instance, in March 2025, in the Dagestani city of Buynaksk, an elderly woman died after being attacked by stray dogs. Authorities reported on the work of animal capture specialists, but residents interviewed by the "Caucasian Knot" stated that they did not notice any results.
Translated automatically via OpenAI from https://www.kavkaz-uzel.eu/articles/428384





![Tumso Abdurakhmanov. Screenshot from video posted by Abu-Saddam Shishani [LIVE] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mIR3s7AB0Uw Tumso Abdurakhmanov. Screenshot from video posted by Abu-Saddam Shishani [LIVE] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mIR3s7AB0Uw](/system/uploads/article_image/image/0001/18460/main_image_Tumso.jpg)